Robby Amaro — Family · Growth · Leadership

Everything Can't Be Priority One Priority 1 Priority 1 Priority 1 Priority 1 Priority 1 Priority 1 Priority 1 Priority 1 Priority 1 Priority 1 say what gets pushed.

Robby Amaro ·

If you add a new top priority, you owe somebody an answer: what gets pushed?

I want everything done tomorrow. Most founders do. When a company is growing, every week brings a new idea that looks like the most important thing in the world.

That's fine for me. You can tell me something is the top priority today, and tomorrow I'll forget about it and go find whatever matters most that day. That's just how my brain works.

It took me a long time to learn that a lot of great people don't work that way. And if you lead them like they do, you'll burn out the people you can least afford to lose.

Some people carry every priority you ever gave them

There's a type of operator every company needs. They execute exactly the way you asked. They build the system, learn every exception, and keep the machine running whether you're watching or not.

Here's the catch. They don't drop things. The thing you called urgent a month ago is still urgent in their head. So is the one from two weeks ago. And then you add a new one on Monday.

The picture I keep coming back to is a truck with tires piling on. Every new priority is another tire, and they're carrying all of them. They aren't letting any go, because you never told them they could.

So from their side, the question is simple. What's the actual priority? If you don't answer it, the answer is all of them. Everything is number one. And their day isn't done until they've pushed every one of them forward as far as they can.

That's how a really good person ends up working all day and night on four "top" projects at once.

They usually won't tell you

This is the part that sneaks up on you. A lot of these people will never say they're too busy. They won't ask for help. They'll just absorb it.

The signs are quieter. Hours creep up. Small things slip. Then you ask, "What are your priorities right now?" and the answer is "Everything."

When I hear that, it's not a performance problem. It's a leadership problem. Nobody told them what to stop.

The fix: say what gets pushed

What worked for me was almost embarrassingly simple. This week, it's these two things. That's it. Next week, we're doing this one.

And when something new jumps the line, I say what it bumps. Out loud. "This is the top priority now, so that project moves to next week, and this one moves to next month." Something has to give, and they need to hear which thing it is.

A few things that help:

This week

Keep

These two things.

Push

Next week, or later.

Cut

Into the backlog. Say it out loud.

None of this is heavy process. It's just saying the quiet part: not everything is happening this week.

Your best people shouldn't do your cheapest work

There's a related trap. Highly capable people will grab repetitive, low-level work because it's in front of them and they can do it. Scheduling, coordinating, chasing small stuff. Every one of those little tasks eats more time than it looks like it should.

They won't take that work off their own plate. You have to keep taking it away. Sometimes that means hiring help for the repetitive stuff so your strongest operator can stay on the work only they can do.

If you're the one carrying the tires

If you're on the other side of this, here's what I'd tell you.

You probably already know the best next move. Your gut is telling you something. Follow it, and push back.

Show your leader the list. Here's everything on my plate. Here's the order I'd do it in, starting with the highest-leverage move. Here's realistic timing. Then use your time together to argue about the order, not to quietly do all of it.

And when someone wants a big new idea live by next week, it's okay to say: this is a three-month project, not a three-day one. Here's what we can do now while we build the better version. Big ideas can be genius and still not happen tomorrow. It can't all be done at once.

It keeps changing, and that's normal

Growth makes a mess for everybody. The priorities you set this month will be wrong next month. A swing in spend or a new product can change half the list overnight.

That's not a reason to stop setting priorities. It's the reason to do it every week.

There's a good part, too. When you're consistent about what moves and why, people start learning how you think. Not every detail of the strategy. The principles. What gets you excited, what you'll cut, how you weigh things. Pretty soon they're getting ahead of you. "Last time this happened you told me to do X. Should we do that again?"

That's the goal. Not a person who does everything at once. A person who knows what matters this week, and has permission to let the rest wait.

So if you lead people, try this on Monday. Ask each of them what their top priorities are. If the answer is "everything," that's on you. Pick two. Push the rest. Tell them out loud.

That's where I'm at right now.

Stay in touch.

Get new posts and the occasional launch update straight to your inbox—weekly, or when there’s something new worth sharing. Join the list. Emails start in 2027.

If I’m not for you, don’t subscribe. All good—just come back and visit :)